We look at:
Key TakeawaysWhat Is a Costs Budget and Why It MattersHow Costs Budgets Fit into the Litigation TimetableWhen Can You Apply to Vary a Costs BudgetThe Procedure for Varying a Costs BudgetCompleting Precedent TReaching Agreement with the Other PartyApplying to the Court If Agreement Cannot Be ReachedWhy Promptness Affects Your Costs RecoveryCommon Mistakes That Undermine a Variation ApplicationFrequently Asked QuestionsHow Do You Prepare a Costs Budget?Why Do Costs Budgets Change?When Must a Costs Budget Be Filed?Acting Promptly on Costs Budget Variations Protects Your Cost RecoveryVarying a Costs Budgets – What is the Procedure?
If you’re involved in a commercial, property, or construction claim, it’s alarming when you find your costs have altered significantly from the original budget and costs management order.
Cases can be unpredictable and new unforeseen costs and expenses arise — understanding the commercial dynamics of litigation is vital to acting quickly and protecting your position.
We act for parties actively involved in civil cases across England and Wales, providing a dedicated costs management service for litigants and in-house legal teams. For clear and prompt advice, contact our specialist litigation solicitors. Our team act nationally and would love to help you.
Key Takeaways
- Budgeting for costs takes place at an early stage in a civil claim
- Costs budgets are designed to ensure proportionality, reasonableness and transparency
- Budgets are agreed between the parties and/or approved by the court at a costs and case management hearing
- A costs budget can be varied later if there are significant developments; this helps manage unforeseen costs and expenses
- There are strict rules and requirements about varying a budget which must be done promptly before additional costs and expenses are incurred
- Variations to costs budget cannot be agreed between the parties or approved by the court without evidence of significant developments
What Is a Costs Budget and Why It Matters
A costs budget is a document prepared by both sides in a civil litigation case. It contains an estimate of how much each party expects their legal costs to trial to be. It’s usually only cases allocated to the multi-track which require a costs budget.
A budget projects costs and expenses against every stage of the litigation process. Depending on the court your matter is preceding in this will either be prepared on a Precedent H or Precedent Z Costs Budget form. It requires a prediction of work needed to pursue or defend the case to trial together with an estimate of the reasonable and proportionate costs of doing so.
Costs budgeting is a mechanism to control legal costs and expenses so that a winning party is only able to recover legal costs incurred reasonably and proportionately from the losing party, with the expectation that this will encourage litigants to only incur reasonable and proportionate costs in the first place. A costs budget is subject to approval by the court, and the budgeting process is set out in the Civil Procedure Rules (CPR).
How Costs Budgets Fit into the Litigation Timetable
We must prepare and submit a Precedent H costs budget at an early stage. It is exchanged with the other parties and then filed with the court when a case is allocated to the multi-track.
For claims valued at less than £50,000, a budget must be exchanged and filed with the directions questionnaires. In other cases, the deadline is no later than 21 days before the first case management conference.
When Can You Apply to Vary a Costs Budget
It can be challenging to accurately forecast costs and expenses which have yet to be incurred, so the CPR makes provision for variations to a costs budget. If your costs are likely to exceed what you originally budgeted, you can apply to vary the budget.
There’s always been a process under the Civil Procedure Rules for parties to vary their costs budget. However, from 1 October 2020, this became a defined rule: CPR 3.15A.
This rule allows for a revised budget called a Precedent T variation if there have been ‘significant developments’.
The Procedure for Varying a Costs Budget
Completing Precedent T
Precedent T or Precedent TZ (depending on the court your matter is proceeding in) is a document that either party can use to explain and justify changes to their budget based on significant developments in the case.
The Variation Particulars section lists details of the additional costs. The forms allow for experts’ fees if they’re part of the variation and a breakdown of these must be included.
The court completes the final column once the variation is approved.
Reaching Agreement with the Other Party
You serve Precedent T or TZ on all the other parties and include certification that the additional costs have not been included in any previous budgets or variations.
The other parties can comment on the variation and suggest an alternative if they don’t agree. The proposed variation ultimately requires the consent of all the parties, and the court must be notified. If they can’t agree, then the court will decide.
Applying to the Court If Agreement Cannot Be Reached
If the parties can’t agree on the variation, you submit Precedent T or TZ to the court with the latest agreed budget, and an explanation of why the parties disagree on the variation.
The court can approve or reject the variations against the context of significant developments which have occurred in the case since the last budget was agreed. The court can also ask for another costs management hearing.
Why Promptness Affects Your Costs Recovery
It’s sensible to prepare and file Precedent T or TZ before you incur new costs. Even though the court has discretion to allow expenses incurred before the variation, it is not required to and may reject them based on fairness to the other parties.
Essentially, act quickly so you can get a variation agreed before expenses are incurred. Otherwise, you run the risk the court will reject the variation exposing you to the potential of being unable to recover those additional costs in the event you win the court proceedings.
Common Mistakes That Undermine a Variation Application
- Presenting a costs variation against changes that are not classified as significant developments. There is no standard definition of significant developments, so interpretation is based on context and previous case decisions
- Incurring costs ahead of a variation only to find the court doesn’t approve them. In some cases, the court has taken a strong stand on variation applications that have not been submitted promptly
- Not being able to demonstrate significant developments and prompt action: both are required for a variation application to succeed. Variation is not a mechanism for you to go back and amend a previous costs order just because it was poorly prepared or is inaccurate
- Opposing parties cannot agree themselves to vary the costs budget; there must still be evidence of a significant development and the approval of the court
Litigating parties often fail to understand that the obligations in relation to costs fall upon them and start from the moment they instruct a solicitor. This places a burden on you as a party to the case to thoroughly research and present all the evidence, so the original budget is as accurate as possible. However, litigation is unpredictable and sometimes applying for a variation is unavoidable, but obtaining it is never guaranteed.
Frequently Asked Questions
How Do You Prepare a Costs Budget?
The budgeting process is partly dictated by the type of case and its value. In simple terms, the litigation is divided into phases. An estimate is recorded for the time and cost of each phase. Costs include the solicitor’s time, and any disbursements such as fees for counsel and expert witnesses.
Why Do Costs Budgets Change?
Costs budgets alter if a case changes significantly or there are unexpected developments. It’s essential to obtain full and detailed case evidence as soon as possible to support an accurate estimate. The option exists to vary a costs budget, but it must be done quickly before the new costs or disbursements are incurred.
When Must a Costs Budget Be Filed?
For claims under £50,000, a costs budget must be filed with the directions questionnaire. For higher value claims, the deadline is at least 21 clear days before the first Case Management Conference. If a party fails to file a Costs Budget at the appropriate time, under CPR 3.14, the court will treat the party as having filed a budget for court fees only, in other words seriously limiting the recoverable costs.
Acting Promptly on Costs Budget Variations Protects Your Cost Recovery
If you’re already involved in civil litigation, it can be alarming when you discover your costs budget is not keeping pace with real-time costs and expenses. It’s possible to vary your budget mid-case, but you need to have defined grounds to do this and must act promptly before additional expenses are incurred.
We’re litigation solicitors with specialist costs management knowledge, helping claimants and legal teams revise expenses budgets and prepare applications for variation. Our advice is rapid, specialist, realistic, and strategic, so you can keep pace with unforeseen developments in your case.
If you’re watching your costs spiral, contact our specialist litigation team today for a no-cost, no-obligation initial conversation. Our team have decades of experience working with complex disputes ranging in value from tens of thousands to tens of millions in dispute. We would love to help you.