We look at:
Key TakeawaysWhy the Pay Less Notice Deadline Leaves No Room for ErrorWhat a Valid Pay Less Notice Must ContainThe Mistakes That Make a Pay Less Notice DefectiveGetting the Dates WrongNot Enough Detail on How the Sum Was CalculatedServing It on the Wrong RecipientDefective ServiceThe Consequence: Smash and Grab AdjudicationPay First, Argue Later: What Happens After a Failed NoticeFrequently Asked QuestionsHow Long Do You Have to Serve a Pay Less Notice?Can a Payment Notice Be a Pay Less Notice?What Are the Requirements for Pay Less Notices Under the Housing Grants, Construction and Regeneration Act?What Should a Pay Less Notice Include?Getting Pay Less Notices Right Protects Your Cash Flow and Reduces Dispute Risk 

Pay Less Notices — Common Mistakes Made by Contractors and Employers

As construction industry professionals, you’ll be aware of the importance of pay less notices. 

Errors can render a pay less notice invalid, and an invalid notice means the full amount on the payment notice falls due, impacting cash flow and financial stability.

We act for contractors and employers on construction projects in England and Wales. If you’re worried about issuing a pay less notice, our specialist construction disputes team can guide you through the requirements while protecting your commercial interests. Our construction team have decades of experience dealing in matters like yours and we are happy to help.

Key Takeaways

  • Pay less notices offer vital protection to employers against overpayments
  • To be valid, the document must contain specific information and be correctly served 
  • It’s easy to make a simple procedural error rendering a notice invalid
  • A defective notice can mean you are liable for the full amount the other party has asked for, regardless of the integrity of the work 
  • A defective notice allows contractors and subcontractors to instigate a smash and grab adjudication and apply for an award for the full amount claimed

Why the Pay Less Notice Deadline Leaves No Room for Error

A pay less notice must be served before the final payment date specified in the contract, which is typically seven days prior. You can find out more about pay less notices in our comprehensive article.

NEC (New Engineering Contract) and JCT (Joint Contracts Tribunal) contracts often set their own deadline for serving a pay less notice, which can be shorter than the statutory default — so always check the specific clause in your contract.

If the contract is silent or its payment provisions are unlawful, then the Scheme for Construction Contracts under the Housing Grants, Construction and Regeneration Act 1996 specifies seven days before the final date for payment.

However, whatever the deadline is, it is non-negotiable and an absolute requirement. So, if you’re even just a day later, you’re late, and the notice is invalid. Contracts can undergo amendments. It’s important to stay in touch with these as the deadline for pay less notices may alter as the project progresses.

What a Valid Pay Less Notice Must Contain

  • The amount you consider due — this could be a reduced sum or zero
  • A clear explanation of how you’ve calculated this with any deductions or offsets
  • Any relevant attachments that support the revised figure
  • The project reference
  • The correct addressee and address details
  • The date

The Mistakes That Make a Pay Less Notice Defective

Getting the Dates Wrong

If you don’t serve the notice at the correct time, irrespective of whether that’s a genuine oversight or for a good reason (even if you’re just a day late), then it’s invalid.

You’ll have to pay the full amount applied for immediately, even if it’s wrong.

Not Enough Detail on How the Sum Was Calculated

Vague claims without a transparent financial breakdown or rationale will cause a pay less notice to fail. The reasons for the revised figure must be clearly set out. 

Serving It on the Wrong Recipient

The notice must be served on the correct recipient, usually specified in the contract.

Defective Service

Failing to serve the notice correctly, even if the recipient and date are correct and the notice is valid in all other respects, can invalidate it. The correct method of service is usually laid out in the construction contract.

The Consequence: Smash and Grab Adjudication

Smash and grab adjudications are so called because the payee can refer the dispute to adjudication and will typically receive an award for the full amount claimed purely by relying on some procedural or administrative defect in the pay less notice. 

Smash and grab adjudications are not usually concerned with the scope or detail of the work.

Pay First, Argue Later: What Happens After a Failed Notice

Paying first and arguing later is a principle designed to keep construction projects on track and avoid delays which can prove terminal. 

However, this can mean an unwelcome financial liability as you may be paying for work which hasn’t been completed or is of inadequate quality.

To challenge a pay less notice or smash and grab award, you’ll need to start a true value adjudication that reviews the actual work completed against the amount paid.

A true value adjudication doesn’t guarantee you’ll recover the full sum — outcomes depend on the merits of the underlying work, and adjudicators retain discretion.

Frequently Asked Questions

How Long Do You Have to Serve a Pay Less Notice?

The deadline is whatever your contract specifies — commonly seven days before the final payment date. If the contract is silent, the Scheme for Construction Contracts applies the same seven-day period. Late pay less notices are deemed invalid even if they’re accurate in content and service, so always stay up-to-date with contract amendments.

Can a Payment Notice Be a Pay Less Notice?

No. A payment notice tells the payee the sum due (the notified sum) for work completed. A pay less notice is the paying party’s separate response, stating an intention to pay less than that sum. They’re distinct documents with different purposes.

What Are the Requirements for Pay Less Notices Under the Housing Grants, Construction and Regeneration Act?

The Act contains a list of requirements necessary for a pay less notice to be valid. As well as the correct contents, a pay less notice must be in writing and served on the correct person within the deadline specified in either the construction contract or legislation.

What Should a Pay Less Notice Include?

A pay less notice should include the revised amount and why there is a difference. There must be calculations and financial information which support this and attachments if relevant. The notice must also include the project reference, the identity of the correct addressee, their address, and the date.

Getting Pay Less Notices Right Protects Your Cash Flow and Reduces Dispute Risk 

Pay less notices exist to prevent underpayment and overpayment and are designed to manage the inevitable fluctuations that are a hallmark of most construction projects.

They reflect differences in quality or scope, or any delays, and ensure payment disputes are addressed quickly to avoid undermining the entire project.

Understanding pay less notices and how to use them protects your cash flow and promotes stable financial management. Used correctly, they also ensure you only pay the correct amount for work completed.

Early legal advice helps protect your position and reduces the risks of disputes. We provide specialist and strategic advice, helping contractors and employers draft and serve pay less notices. Subject to case assessment and our funding criteria, we may offer a Conditional Fee Arrangement (CFA / No Win No Fee) on qualifying construction disputes typically valued over £10,000 with strong prospects of success.

Before you issue a pay less notice, or if you’re in a dispute about a building project, contact our specialist construction disputes team. We act nationally and would love to help you.